Issue 146: Property P139 has alternative form should have its own "has type" property.

ID: 
146
Starting Date: 
2007-03-16
Working Group: 
1
Status: 
Done
Closing Date: 
2008-05-12
Background: 

The property P139 has alternative form should have its own has type property (P139.1). This would allow us to deal with the FRAD attribute "transliteration scheme of name" of the Name entity.

Paris 14/3/2007

Current Proposal: 

The property P139 has alternative form should have its own has type property (P139.1). This would allow us to deal with the FRAD attribute "transliteration scheme of name" of the Name entity. Property P139.1 is therefore created. Also, the scope note for P139 is rewritten as follows:

This property establishes a relationship of synonymy between two instances of E41 Appellation, independent from any item identified by them. The property is a dynamic, asymmetric relationship, where the domain expresses a derivative, if such a direction can be established. Otherwise, the relationship is symmetric.

The synonymy applies to all cases of use of an instance of E41 Appellation. Multiple names assigned to an object, which, are not always synonymous should be instantiated as repeated values of the is identified by property. This property is not transitive.

P139.1 has type allows the type of derivation, such as transliteration from Latin 1 to ASCII be refined.

Edinburg 10/7/2007

Outcome: 

P139 has alternative form

Domain: E41 Appellation
Range: E41 Appellation
Quantification: many to many (0,n:0,n)
Scope note:

This property establishes a relationship of equivalence between two instances of E41 Appellation independent from any item identified by them. It is a dynamic asymmetric relationship, where the range expresses the derivative, if such a direction can be established. Otherwise, the relationship is symmetric.

The equivalence applies to all cases of use of an instance of E41 Appellation. Multiple names assigned to an object, which are not equivalent for all things identified with a specific instance of E41 Appellation, should be modelled as repeated values of the "is identified by" property. This property is symmetric but not transitive.
Examples:
  1. "Martin Doerr" (E41) has alternative form "Martin Doerr" (E41) has type Alternate spelling (E55)
  2. "Гончарова, Наталья Сергеевна" (E41) has alternative form "Gončarova, Natal Sergeevna" (E41) has type ISO 9:1995 transliteration (E55)
  3. Αθήνα has alternative form Athina has type transcription.
Properties: P139.1 has type: E55 Type

Nuremberg 4-7 December 2007

 

Accepted

Heraklion, May 2008